Has anyone noticed the escalation in rhetoric regarding Iran in, say, the past 2 weeks? Doesn’t it sound a bit 2002ish? You know… pre-Iraq? You only have to listen to the rhetoric spewed by Stephen Green to realize we are on the brink of yet another war.
Iran is now three years away, maybe less, from building nuclear weapons. They already posses the means to deliver those weapons to Israel and even parts of Europe. Yes, the people of Iran still have a chance to throw off the Mullah’s yoke. But now that nukes are in the equation, along with specific threats to us them, we have to grade their chance on a curve: A three year curve at most.
There has been talk of “letting” Israel settle the problem – using their own nukes. With 300 nuclear weapons sites scattered across Iran, that solution is problematical at best, and morally reprehensible in any case. What that means is, we do have to start thinking, quite seriously, about regime change in Iran. However, our thoughts should take into account Iran’s organic tendencies towards democratization.
I read James’ piece with a grain of salt. I am not opposed to military action in Iran. I don’t support it either. In fact, I would say that I have a dull ache in my war gland. It’s sort of numb. Another war? Another 3, 5, 7 years of an all volunteer military being stretched across the middle east? More lawyer, doctor, concrete worker, building framer, human resources representative warriors deployed away from their livelihoods and families?
I’m numb because I don’t know what more this country can take. We have not yet been asked to sacrifice anything except our privacy and good will. What happens when we are? What happens when the need comes to supplement the troops and the only means to do so is via a draft? What happens when domestic support for the troops wanes (a la Vietnam)? What happens when a war tax is put into place that, along with all our other taxes, drains over 50% of our collective incomes (a la World War II)? What if the intelligence of the world is wrong again? Are we that far removed from the pre-war intelligence of 2002-2003 that this possibility doesn’t exist?
I’m not discounting another war as a very possible, and possibly a very necessary action. I’m afraid that we really won’t have an option. My gut instinct is that Bush is reluctant in this case. He’s taken a beating over Iraq in the world and at home and I think he’ll be a bit more cautious with another war… (three in one administration… that has to be a record). What if we don’t have an option? Do we have the will? Collectively? As a nation? I don’t know. I just don’t know. And I’m numb about it.

{ 18 comments }
Jeremy Wright 01.17.06 at 9:46 am
I was flipping past CNN the other day and they had a 1-hour special on it. Scared the crap out of me. Somebody, somewhere, is turning up the heat.
Jeremy Wright 01.17.06 at 9:46 am
I was flipping past CNN the other day and they had a 1-hour special on it. Scared the crap out of me. Somebody, somewhere, is turning up the heat.
Aaron 01.17.06 at 9:57 am
Yeah it’s getting hot, that’s for sure. I can’t say whether I support this or not. I’m scared to death, to be honest… for our military, for our nation, for our president!! But it sure seems like the endgame is already written and being played out.
Aaron 01.17.06 at 9:57 am
Yeah it’s getting hot, that’s for sure. I can’t say whether I support this or not. I’m scared to death, to be honest… for our military, for our nation, for our president!! But it sure seems like the endgame is already written and being played out.
David Nick 01.17.06 at 11:44 am
Call me an optomist you guys, but I don’t see us launching a war against Iran, contrary to what CNN or any other liberal media would scare you into believing. That doesn’t mean it won’t occur, I’m simply saying that Bush could not afford nor survive launching a war this late in his political game. Now, if Iran does something to provoke a response, I’m certain we would aid whoever went in, like a UN force, or Israel, or maybe even Europe (which is highly unlikely since France pretty much likes to believe they are running the EU). But we won’t be going after them like we went after Iraq.
Like I said, that’s simply based on my own opinion, and what I’ve read.
But all it takes is Iran to launch a scud based nuke towards Israel or Jordan and all bets are off.
:)
David Nick 01.17.06 at 11:44 am
Call me an optomist you guys, but I don’t see us launching a war against Iran, contrary to what CNN or any other liberal media would scare you into believing. That doesn’t mean it won’t occur, I’m simply saying that Bush could not afford nor survive launching a war this late in his political game. Now, if Iran does something to provoke a response, I’m certain we would aid whoever went in, like a UN force, or Israel, or maybe even Europe (which is highly unlikely since France pretty much likes to believe they are running the EU). But we won’t be going after them like we went after Iraq.
Like I said, that’s simply based on my own opinion, and what I’ve read.
But all it takes is Iran to launch a scud based nuke towards Israel or Jordan and all bets are off.
:)
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:23 pm
I’m scared to think where we will be if Iran does acquire nuclear weapons. I have to agree with David though regarding “going after Iran like we went after Irag.” We won’t invade Iran, because we don’t have to. Airpower and some well placed bunker busters will do the job. Israel knows where the sites are located you can be sure of that. I see us taking out their nuclear facilities with the possible help of the EU and Israel if they continue down the current road… We cannot, the world cannot allow Iran, the mullah’s and the crazy bastard Mohammad Khatami to get their hands on WMD’s…
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:23 pm
I’m scared to think where we will be if Iran does acquire nuclear weapons. I have to agree with David though regarding “going after Iran like we went after Irag.” We won’t invade Iran, because we don’t have to. Airpower and some well placed bunker busters will do the job. Israel knows where the sites are located you can be sure of that. I see us taking out their nuclear facilities with the possible help of the EU and Israel if they continue down the current road… We cannot, the world cannot allow Iran, the mullah’s and the crazy bastard Mohammad Khatami to get their hands on WMD’s…
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:25 pm
I agree, Mike. We can’t allow Iran to follow through on this path. I just shudder to think what that means for us in the long run.
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:25 pm
I agree, Mike. We can’t allow Iran to follow through on this path. I just shudder to think what that means for us in the long run.
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:25 pm
Hey Mike– You ever gonna update your blog? ;)
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:25 pm
Hey Mike– You ever gonna update your blog? ;)
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:28 pm
I agree, and we cannot afford another ground war… I believe Bush will support a strike though. Israel has March as their deadline so we’ll have to see what their actions are in the next month…
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:28 pm
I agree, and we cannot afford another ground war… I believe Bush will support a strike though. Israel has March as their deadline so we’ll have to see what their actions are in the next month…
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:29 pm
Yeah, I’ve was just looking at it yesterday and have to get back in the saddle, somewhat…
Mike 01.17.06 at 4:29 pm
Yeah, I’ve was just looking at it yesterday and have to get back in the saddle, somewhat…
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:44 pm
I’ve got you in my RSS reader…
Aaron 01.17.06 at 4:44 pm
I’ve got you in my RSS reader…
Comments on this entry are closed.